This is a scary time for European trees, since it was first discovered, Phytophthora ramorum and some of its relatives have not abated. The spread of the disease has not been halted despite some serious investment and efforts by the FC and DEFRA in the UK and their European counterparts. Recent news that the spread is as a result of sporangia in Larch plantations is a massive new problem.
With most EU countries now adopting austerity measures or cuts to public spending, how much will the budgets of the organisations dealing with this problem be affected. This is already answerable and we know that funding has been dramatically reduced and will continue to be reduced.
However how much are the public involved in the assistance to halt the spread of the disease and also how much are the practitioners involved? How much are the nursery and horticultural industry responsible for the outbreak of P. ramorum and other diseases in the first place? And as such what measures should we in the industry be taking.
The FC have produced guidelines and introduced what appears to be an excellent and comprehensive package - advocating increased vigilance and following discovery serious efforts to curb spread through cleaning of tools, clothing, vehicles and staff. Following removal of the infected plants, replanting instructions are provided. Financial aid is also given to landowners who have large outbreaks.
This does not alleviate the frustration many practitioners and owners must feel about being unable to stop the spread of the disease in the first place.
It was evident to some that an outbreak of P. kernovia in Cornwall was spreading in localised areas away from land that saw public access on a large scale but that P. ramorum seemed to occur in areas which did see significant public access. On one plant I saw that had been affected it was evident that the Rhododendron in question had been clipped for cuttings by someone who did not work on the estate in question. Dirty secateurs by a cutting thief? The suggestion for controls to persons, animals and vehicles moving in and out of areas with the disease has been suggested plenty of times but restrictions have not been forthcoming in any tangible amount.
Media reaction has been largely good, the fear and horror angle of these diseases appeals to the public and consequently much has been written - surely aiding those tasked with trying to halt the diseases. Or maybe the cynics amongst us will think that this publicity was counter productive, media hype about a threat that is hardly the end of the world, leading to a slow down in funding.
With the recent news about the spread and the fact that budgets will certainly be lowered now it is surely the time to trust the practitioners to do more than just report on the disease and clean their boots regularly.
The current position of the UK land industry is well placed to assist: It is largely made up of smaller, localised but highly knowledgeable professionals. Many of whom are trusted by their clients to a degree unseen in many other industries. With a threat as great as this it is surely essential to arm those already trained in horticulture and land based industry with more than a 'mopping up' information sheet. The practitioners could already be out there helping to ensure; new planting is carried out to minimise the risks; checking up on the supply chain of plants; removing highly susceptible plants from contact with important native and ornamental trees and other significant specimens; warning clients directly; testing products and having the right to impose restrictions on high risk areas when concerned without waiting in consultation, etc.,
Quangos have frequently kept operations to themselves, but with these new threats and with the budget cuts looming it is surely time to allow the practitioners to relieve some of the burden of the work ahead in fighting these diseases. Indeed the existing base of practitioners, their knowledge and access to materials and different techniques specific for different regions is surely a good place to look for potential solutions or experimentation in reducing the continued spread.
Votes: 0
E-mail me when people leave their comments –


  • The last but one paragraph above has some extremely valid points as to action that should be taken withregards the above mentioned diseases.
    I have heard that a certain nationally well known trust/society had a sale in one of it's properties here in Cornwall selling off all it's stock of Rhododendron ponticum, a main vector P.ramorum, before receiving a visit by the group set up to examine the spread of these diseases in the UK. Did they know of the intended visit?
    Other properties are able to refuse access to their grounds so as to make it impossible for these diseases to be found/eradicated. WHY are they allowed to do this?
    The Lost Gardens of Heligan removed all R.ponticum and cleared all leaves/debris from underneath all other Rhododendron species to negate the possibility that these diseases might get a foothold in their grounds. A RESPONSIBLE act.
    They have also had the micro-propogation unit at Rosewarne, Camborne successfully propogate large numbers of rhodos which they declare to be disease free. This work is being carried out on Camellia's as well. This not only stops spreading the disease, but also the plants grown are from the original plantings from over 150 years ago, saving the heritage of the gardens.
    WE in our small business ALWAYS spray secateurs, loppers, saws etc with anti-bacterial spray before leaving a garden and going to the next. A small thing maybe but we work with many of the species that are affected by these Phytophora's every week and take this threat very seriously and are always checking out any discolouration etc on plant leaves just in case. Maybe we should implement a boot wash as well, after all if we find either of the above in a garden whom will the owner blame for it's appearance?
    After all if Phytophora spreads then we all face losing clients, so Patsy and I back any call for greater regulation/control with this issue.
  • I was working for a large garden on the Helford river when the outbreaks were being discovered, we were given the information sheets and fore warned of a potential visit at least a month in advance. We had 2 affected shrubs - which had both displayed signs of 'having cuttings taken from them'. This was P. kernovia, which when I went to see the worst outbreak beside a popular Nursery which had affected mature Native Oaks it was scary. The nursery and the landowner concerned had a full team paid by the FC/DEFRA to tackle the situation. The landowner I was working for paid for his own team and work was done well within the given timeframe. This nursery close to the outbreak, (not the same one you are talking about as it is not National), should not have been allowed to continue selling stock as it was in the exclusion zone - but I know it simply carted off the stock to another Nursery. Such callous acts were simply illegal. But it was evident that the larger the business the more assistance they were given and there was an awful lot of abuse and ignoring of the real threat.

    Personally I think that every single 'relevant' person should have been taken to the outbreak site to see the damage and as such the flippancy which occurred may have been avoided.
This reply was deleted.

You need to be a member of Landscape Juice Network to add comments!

Join Landscape Juice Network

Open forum activity

Andrew Midgley replied to Andrew Midgley's discussion Feedback on Eliet Maestro Country Shredder/Chipper
"Thanks for the feedbacks chaps; much appreciated.  Food for thoughts certainly.
2 hours ago
Creon mackay and Rich Hughes joined Landscape Juice Network
2 hours ago
Peter sellers replied to Andrew Midgley's discussion Feedback on Eliet Maestro Country Shredder/Chipper
"We bought two Eliet Majors some time ago and they are ok for woody prunings such as conifer etc but anything soft and sappy will block them, when we bought ours they had the option of an additional coarse screen which has large square holes rather t…"
3 hours ago
Fusion Media posted a blog post
From groundsman to greenkeeper, contractor to sales advisor – the experienced Allan Wright has turned his hand to most jobs in the turf and amenity industry.“In all of the positions that I’ve had in my career, I’ve always looked at the next step as…
6 hours ago
Gaz replied to Gaz's discussion Dying shrub
11 hours ago
Gaz replied to Gaz's discussion Dying shrub
11 hours ago
Gaz posted a discussion
I wonder if anyone has come across this or any advice. One of my customers has what I think is a Japanese has been doing very well but since my last visit 2 weeks ago half of it appears to have died (see photos) some of the bottom of the…
11 hours ago
Colin Hunt replied to Andrew Midgley's discussion Feedback on Eliet Maestro Country Shredder/Chipper
"I have an Eliet Major and TBH has been my most disapointing buy. The problem was at the time of purchase, the entry level small chipper was £4k, the Eliet was around £1.8, so I thought it would do a job. Biggest problems, it will only draw in woody…"
14 hours ago
John F replied to Trevor Stephens's discussion Our own Gardens....
"Thinking ahead i grassed it over years ago for easy low maintenance but plants can be a bit like sweets and irresistable so borders have crept back creating work . 
The garden hedge i decided to shape like an elephant but currently its looking like…"
15 hours ago
David Benson replied to Andrew Midgley's discussion Feedback on Eliet Maestro Country Shredder/Chipper
"cannot recall which moddel it was but looks simular to the country, had use of one in a large garden i did a few years ago 
it was a pain to get into the garden as it was top heavey it used to bung up with soft green waste tried saving woody stuff t…"
21 hours ago
Mark Fraser and ANDREA BOZZI joined Landscape Juice Network
22 hours ago
David Benson replied to Trevor Stephens's discussion Our own Gardens....
"grass always cut as and when keep the front garden tyder than the back just incace a client came to the door but my garden is a spring garden so at the moment it looks bad "
22 hours ago
David Benson replied to GaryRK's discussion Best industry T / Polo shirt
"i find t shirts too warm thin cotton shirts for me long lightweight trousers and boots"
22 hours ago
Andrew Midgley replied to Andrew Midgley's discussion Eliet E401 scarifier
"Thank s Mark for your responses. I am getting my faithful Allen Turf Doctor repaired with new bearings as they were shot and probably keep it for larger lawns and for tougher jobs. I am thinking the Eliet will be more than good enough for my needs."
22 hours ago
Andrew Coates replied to Andrew Coates's discussion How do you tackle this one folks
"Thanks Graham and Sean for your advice"
23 hours ago
GaryRK replied to GaryRK's discussion Best industry T / Polo shirt
"A another one via Allen Mowers : "
23 hours ago

Dying shrub

I wonder if anyone has come across this or any advice. One of my customers has what I think is a Japanese has been doing very well but since my last visit 2 weeks ago half of it appears to have died (see photos) some of the bottom of the…

Read more…
2 Replies · Reply by Gaz 11 hours ago