Towards Modern Design?

On another thread on LJN I recently posted a comment lamenting the innate conservatism of design in this country.  The context of that comment belongs to a different discussion, but I think the point is worth exploring for its own sake.

If contemporary garden and landscape design is going to look at it best then it needs a suitable backdrop in just the same way that modern buildings need to be given an appropriate context in the nature of their setting.  The general drift of modern architecture towards clean graphic buildings with multi-purpose living spaces, a focus on the use of new materials used honestly and an air of informality is not yet reflected in the buildings that are still being built in their thousands by the big developers.  There are some exceptions of course, but for the most part these emerging design trends remain a lusted-for ideal in the pages of the design glossies.

 

Yes, it really exists! Perhaps it's an extreme example, but it's pretty amazing...

 

Part of the problem (in design terms) is that in the UK we have such a vast stock of period houses – Victorian and Edwardian terraces and semi-detached houses dominate the fringes of all our towns and cities, the watered-down Arts and Crafts style of most of the latter having become the de facto vernacular architecture over much of the UK.  Although these houses are capable of some internal reorganisation they will never manage to achieve the sort of clarity of which a new house is able – even an expensive architect-designed remodelling will ultimately run up against the exterior design: unless the house is demolished a compromise is inevitable.  Since 1945 it seems that, although high-rise and other high density housing has attempted to embrace modern design, new stock of individual houses has generally followed the inter-War pattern, and even today we see otherwise perfectly liveable new houses dressed up as  Edwardian pastiche. 

Faced with this welter of ‘traditional’ housing design it is no wonder that potential clients think they need ‘traditional’ garden design to go with it.  For a designer it’s an equally difficult tightrope walk – creating a garden that will respect and complement the architecture but that also allows a bit of current design flair can be a tricky one to pull off.

 

 

A new vernacular?  Modern design which displays it's local roots.

 

I’d argue that, although there are some refreshingly different new housing developments around, we do not yet have the sort of critical mass that allows us to identify a new vernacular, and given that, it’s no surprise that clients are still requesting ‘traditional’ gardens.  I’d also argue that the use of landscaping on new developments is rarely anything other than atrocious – having got a landscaping plan past planning control it seems that there is little appetite amongst developers to then push the boat out and do a decent job of designing and building the exterior setting for their houses.  It’s all a question of the budget, and the impulse to avoid anything that will detract from the bottom line is a powerful one, especially when the prices for your product are falling anyway.  As a result new projects invariably seem to end up with turf, a conifer and some yellow stained fencing, all jammed into sadly depleted soil over builders’ rubble.

How do we escape this cycle?  Planning control would seem the obvious place to start, and if planners gave more rigorous attention to the detail of some landscaping proposals developers might be encouraged to be more creative and to put more effort into the settings for their houses.  It would also help if developers could be encouraged to start moving away from the notion of the ‘traditional’ house – especially when there is an opportunity to integrate modern design into areas already bulging with ‘traditional’.  One-offs by architects for individual clients are starting to break up the uniformity of the townscape in many areas, but the truly impressive modern development is a rarity outside the largest cities.  Of course the resources available to enable the planning process to contribute in this way are limited, and becoming more so, and the likelihood is remote.

 

The details which derive from the structural use of materials will always have greater integrity than applied decoration or pastiche.

 

In the end it is all about vision – on the part of developers to engage in good, democratic, sustainable and appropriate design, on the part of planners to allow new modes of building into our towns, cities and villages and on the part of landscape architects and garden designers to create spaces and surroundings that complement the structures.  There are good examples out there, but with an ongoing need for affordable and economic housing there is a great opportunity to create the sort of contemporary buildings and spaces that reflect current approaches to design, if only there is the will.  Chucking out the chintz is only the start!

 

The images are courtesy of Mole, an Ely-based office of architects I stumbled across this week - their buildings seem to combine a truly contemporary approach to sustainability and practical design with very beautiful results.

 

Paul Ridley Design

 

Votes: 0
E-mail me when people leave their comments –

Comments

  • PRO
    If only we could break away from tradition!
  • Hi Paul - great article - if only the history buffs would allow contemporary architecture to be visible next to period buildings and streetscapes - then the gardens can move on - when I first moved to London from Australia I was watching a renovation of a building and could not wait to see the extension - how disappointed was I when they tacked on a faux garage door - here is my blog post

    http://www.gardenbeet.com/garden_design_blog/2010/02/23/streetscape...
This reply was deleted.

You need to be a member of Landscape Juice Network to add comments!

Join Landscape Juice Network

Open forum activity

Field Promax updated their profile
20 minutes ago
LawnLegends replied to James King's discussion Cobra RM53SPH-PRO
"i know of a few other guys who have done the same but only purchased last year so long term not sure yet but no complaints from them either on the stihls, agree on th hayters i wish i had not bought new one last year but will phase them out and…"
10 hours ago
Daniel Carlisle is now a member of Landscape Juice Network
12 hours ago
Peel Projects updated their profile
yesterday
Andrew Betteridge replied to John F's discussion Farm Jack
"Many years ago I borrowed a chain hoist from the local knacker yard, when I returned it I had a labourer with me who really was not impressed when I reversed our Transit pickup into the slaughter house so we could stand on the back of it on saw…"
yesterday
Adam Woods replied to John F's discussion Farm Jack
"You can normally find used ones on eBay or Facebook marketplace"
yesterday
Best Gardens replied to John F's discussion Farm Jack
"We use an engine hoist and it's a great bit of kit, so easy to set up and does a great job (this was a large conifer that took 30 minutes to cut down and pull out)"
yesterday
Andrew Trevor replied to James King's discussion Cobra RM53SPH-PRO
"After twenty odd years running 3 hayter 48pros at a time we have found they have declined with each new model both collecting wet grass and reliability so last year we bought a Stihl RM655RS and so far we always choose that over the hayters. If we…"
yesterday
John F replied to John F's discussion Farm Jack
"Hello Adam Many Thanks for this the hydraulic engine lifter is a serious consideration having watched a few of these youtube demonstrations . 
Initially will try and keep it simple with my usual hand tools for shrub removal but there are 106 to…"
yesterday
PBS30, Michael Curling and Tom Hamilton joined Landscape Juice Network
Friday
Robbie posted a blog post
Friday
Tom Hamilton updated their profile
Friday
Kevin Bradnick liked Fleur Voice's blog post FUNGI - THE ANSWER TO EVERYTHING?
Friday
LawnLegends replied to James King's discussion Cobra RM53SPH-PRO
"weibang with high lift blade, i current run weibangs and hayters with the hayter only coming out on dry days as find it useless compared to the weibang which cuts and bags damp/wet grass with ease. cobras i used few years back were ok initially but…"
Friday
Gary Clapham replied to Christopher Lockwood's discussion Stihl sh86c carb adjustment tool
"Yeah it's hit and miss with them, that's why I get them from amazon, easy return if they don't work "
Thursday
Graham Taylor replied to Christopher Lockwood's discussion Stihl sh86c carb adjustment tool
"They're pretty good.............. I've used a couple of those chinese ones before.................about £20 including postage from China.......they look absolutely identical to the "genuine" ones. "
Thursday
More…