So does placing broken bits of pottery in the bottom of patio pots to aid drainage help or hinder your plants?

Well, Which? Gardening has said the technique is a load of crock having carried out a series of controlled tests.

They used 40 ten litre pots and planted five Million Bells Trailing Yellow in each one. The perennial plant was chosen because it is known to get root rot in very damp soil.

During the test the containers were watered and when the plants came into flower there was no difference noted between the pots with broken pottery in and ones without.

Ceri Thomas, editor of Which? Gardening, was part of the team behind the test.

She said: "Despite six-in-ten of gardeners telling us they always use crocks in pots, we found that this made no difference to how well the plants did in our tests.

"In fact, in wet summers crocks can prevent water draining out of the pot and do more harm than good, so think twice before you follow this commonplace habit."

★
★
★
★
★
Votes: 0
E-mail me when people leave their comments –

Comments

  • I do use broken polystyrene in large heavy pots to reduce overall potential weight when root depth is not an issue - terracotta crocks add further weight to a pot/container.

  • PRO

    It gets very hot here in the summer so the plants I put in my pots need all the moisture they can get. I mainly geraniums because they can easily survive if watering is missed, or late.

    I think putting anything into the pots, other than compost, severely reduced the available rooting-zone and will be detrimental to the plants over time.

    I do wonder if the Victorians used to add a bulking agent to reduce the volume of compost, rather than than an aid to drainage?

This reply was deleted.

You need to be a member of Landscape Juice Network to add comments!

Join Landscape Juice Network

Open forum activity

Mjc replied to Mjc's discussion Battery secateurs
"Wow that sounds nasty, hope you've recovered. I had heard that about some of them, I would have thought in these days of elf and safety that the blades would only close whilst the trigger is pressed. "
17 seconds ago
Peter kermarrec replied to Mjc's discussion Battery secateurs
"I have a pair of the Stihl ones and they are excellent you can cut quite thick stuff with ease and it definitely takes the stress out of your hands,the battery life is good as well, just one word of caution and this was down to my stupidity while I…"
25 minutes ago
PGM replied to Mjc's discussion Battery secateurs
"Currently thinking of getting some myself. The Kebtec ones are well reviewed by various gardeners on YouTube, but then so many of them get sent stuff for free it's hard to believe everything they say. I heard the Stiga ones were pretty good too.…"
37 minutes ago
Mjc posted a discussion
Good morning. Thinking of getting some battery secateurs, initially for my wife as she has some arthritis. Have any of you tried and tested any ?  Prob looking at Stihl but then came across Kebtec which I've never heard of before, or maybe Makita…
1 hour ago
Piers Dixon replied to Piers Dixon's discussion Advertising garden maintenance services
"Thanks for your response. Have you actually tried this??"
yesterday
trimmora updated their profile
yesterday
Fusion Media posted a blog post
After 26 years at Radley College, Adam King has seen grounds management evolve dramatically. Weather patterns have become less predictable, playing surfaces are under greater pressure than ever, and flexibility has become one of the most valuable…
yesterday
Fusion Media posted a blog post
GroundsFest has welcomed Christina Walker to its sales team as preparations continue for the 2027 exhibition.Christina joins the award-winning team with an extensive background in publishing and exhibitions spanning more than two decades. She began…
Friday
Fusion Media posted a blog post
When freezing temperatures threaten the pitches at Forest Green Rovers FC, speed is everything. Protecting the stadium and training ground with frost covers can be a race against the weather, but thanks to Kress battery-powered blowers, the club's…
Thursday
Fusion Media posted a blog post
The GroundsFest Academy has confirmed TLS as its newest Platinum Sponsor, adding further industry strength to the Academy's range of sponsors and partners as it continues to expand its training offering for the groundscare sector. The sponsorship…
Thursday
Peter sellers replied to William Baker's discussion Winter Services
"Hi William, I would avoid working as a sub contractor if you can. Yes they will not pay a realistic rate as they will try to keep their profit as high as poss, in my experience getting paid was always an issue. We had a long and profitable…"
Wednesday
Billybop replied to William Baker's discussion Winter Services
"Thanks William, yes a bit like being a retained fire fighter I suppose. Monthly payments for a 12 month contract, knowing that worst case scenario only 6 months or so might require visits. Which could be very few and far between, or more numerous…"
Wednesday
William Baker replied to William Baker's discussion Winter Services
"Hi Richard, thank you for your reply. I've not approached either of these companies as yet, would you suggest Outco and Nurture are good companies to contact, and do you have any experience with either?"
Tuesday
William Baker replied to William Baker's discussion Winter Services
"Hi Peter, thank you very much for such a detailed response, and I'm sorry to hear of your ill health, I do hope you are well. Both of my existing clients that I'm looking to bring on board should be manageable, so they can hopefully help me to dip…"
Tuesday
William Baker replied to William Baker's discussion Winter Services
"Hi Billy, that's a really good idea, even if the contracts are a mix of 'subsciption' and ad-hoc, it at least covers the expense in a worst case scenario. "
Tuesday
Billybop replied to Rob's discussion Best professional battery hedge trimmer at present?
"Hi Tim i wear basic disposable ear plugs with either model if using for any extended period... not so much the volume per se, but it takes the edge off that irritating metallic sound... I think these are being sold for below cost, but heart warming…"
Tuesday
More…

Battery secateurs

Good morning. Thinking of getting some battery secateurs, initially for my wife as she has some arthritis. Have any of you tried and tested any ?  Prob looking at Stihl but then came across Kebtec which I've never heard of before, or maybe Makita…

Read more…
3 Replies · Reply by Mjc 17 seconds ago
Views: 10