So does placing broken bits of pottery in the bottom of patio pots to aid drainage help or hinder your plants?

Well, Which? Gardening has said the technique is a load of crock having carried out a series of controlled tests.

They used 40 ten litre pots and planted five Million Bells Trailing Yellow in each one. The perennial plant was chosen because it is known to get root rot in very damp soil.

During the test the containers were watered and when the plants came into flower there was no difference noted between the pots with broken pottery in and ones without.

Ceri Thomas, editor of Which? Gardening, was part of the team behind the test.

She said: "Despite six-in-ten of gardeners telling us they always use crocks in pots, we found that this made no difference to how well the plants did in our tests.

"In fact, in wet summers crocks can prevent water draining out of the pot and do more harm than good, so think twice before you follow this commonplace habit."

Votes: 0
E-mail me when people leave their comments –

Comments

  • I do use broken polystyrene in large heavy pots to reduce overall potential weight when root depth is not an issue - terracotta crocks add further weight to a pot/container.

  • PRO

    It gets very hot here in the summer so the plants I put in my pots need all the moisture they can get. I mainly geraniums because they can easily survive if watering is missed, or late.

    I think putting anything into the pots, other than compost, severely reduced the available rooting-zone and will be detrimental to the plants over time.

    I do wonder if the Victorians used to add a bulking agent to reduce the volume of compost, rather than than an aid to drainage?

This reply was deleted.

You need to be a member of Landscape Juice Network to add comments!

Join Landscape Juice Network

Open forum activity

Fusion Media posted a blog post
Selected attendees from GroundsFest Academy events were recently given the opportunity to experience a truly unforgettable day at Lord's Cricket Ground, widely regarded as the Home of Cricket. The exclusive experience day offered delegates a…
15 hours ago
Adam Woods replied to Peter sellers's discussion Retirement advice
"The value per client was around how long theyd been with me, the nett profit they generate each year.... and a mad guess at how they will take it if Adam us no longer coming each week... i.e the little old lady who I indulge in a chat  each week...…"
15 hours ago
Peter sellers replied to Peter sellers's discussion Retirement advice
"Adam, thanks - how did you arrive at a" notional " value for each client? Did you value each client on say client a pays me 5k a year and multiply it up for the rest? So for example you had 10 clients all paying 5k a year so that equals 50k income ,…"
yesterday
David Benson replied to David Benson's discussion liquid moss killer
"thanks for the replies i will have a look at them"
yesterday
Adam Woods replied to Peter sellers's discussion Retirement advice
"Hi Peter... sorry been away for a couple of weeks.
So, this is what I did - and it worked.
Made sure I was charging as much as the local market would bear - so I definately was showing a healthy profit - ran the business for near enough a year. Got…"
yesterday
Fusion Media posted a blog post
Cold Ashby Golf Centre in Northamptonshire is enjoying some of the best course conditions in its history – and according to Course Manager Ashley Hammond and long-time member Roger Griffiths, Agrovista Amenity has played a big part in that…
yesterday
Fusion Media posted a blog post
ICL-sponsored award recognises standards in pitch preparation and presentation across GAA venues in Ireland.Hastings MacHale Park, Castlebar, Co. Mayo has been presented with the GAA National Pitch of the Year 2025 award at the League Final in Croke…
yesterday
Anthony Toop replied to Anthony Toop's discussion Servicing battery tools
"Thanks for that, will do.
 "
yesterday
Honey Badger replied to Anthony Toop's discussion Servicing battery tools
"Kma 135r. Take out the drive shaft rod and dip the square end in general purpose grease that will silence it. Machnic at my stihl dealer taught me that. Its worth picking there brains now and then. Also remove the air filter cover clean with a soft…"
Wednesday
Anthony Toop posted a discussion
There doesn't seem to be any manufacturer info available with regards what servicing if any is needed for battery tools, not that i can find anyway.When i say tools, i mean things like the motor end of long reach hedge trimmers, and Kombi motor…
Wednesday
Fusion Media posted a blog post
ICL-sponsored award recognises standards in pitch preparation and presentation across GAA venues in Ireland.Hastings MacHale Park, Castlebar, Co. Mayo has been presented with the GAA National Pitch of the Year 2025 award at the League Final in Croke…
Wednesday
Fusion Media posted a blog post
Pellenc, the pioneer in professional battery-powered tools, is proud to announce the release of the Rasion 3 Easy, a professional-grade 24” (60 cm) self-propelled mower designed to redefine the balance between heavy-duty performance and…
Wednesday
Peter sellers replied to David Benson's discussion liquid moss killer
"Pro kleen liquid iron sulphate direct from Pro kleen around £21 for 2x5lts delivered. We put 2.5lts in a 12lt knapsack, thoroughly wet area, avoid hot windy days.
Have used it for years highly recommend."
Tuesday
Martin Ashdown posted a discussion
We chat over knowing your numbers, eating frogs and RASI forms. Please like and share to help us grow this channel.https://open.spotify.com/episode/0PwhpTOoJrhqiyRRK32qM7?si=252f7534...
Tuesday
Dave Colton replied to David Benson's discussion liquid moss killer
"I haven't use liquid iron but do use soluble iron sulphate, takes a wee bit more mixing as it's a powder but I find it goes further and is cheaper than the liquid, I get mine from agrigem."
Monday
David Benson posted a discussion
i have to treat some small areas of lawn with a lot of paving round them and one area there is a swiming pool. my usual way is lawn sand and a broardcast spredder but this is not ideal for this job, what liquid killer do you recomend for a knapsack…
Monday
More…

how good does this look?

Im looking for my first 100 founding members to join and use canopy and i have approx 65 spaces left.. if your in the UK running a garden maintenance / landscaping company and could be intrested , feel free to enter the waiting list.Thecanopyapp.com

Read more…
0 Replies
Views: 45