LJN Blog Posts

Do Contractors need Designers?

 

This is the title of a seminar to be delivered by Mark Gregory of Landform Consultants and the London College of Garden Design at Landscape, the industry trade show to be held at Olympia on13th and 14th April.  It’s a question that caught my eye, as it addresses an issue that I feel is an unacknowledged elephant in the (exterior design) room, and given that it is eye-catching and that titles are copyright free, I have shamelessly pinched it.  Sorry, Mark.

 

I have no idea where Mark’s discussion will lead, but the fact that he is so closely involved with both sides of the design/build coin suggests that he probably feels as I do: that the answer is as much a ‘yes’ as it would be if the question were reversed – do designers need contractors?

 

 

 

 

There is clearly a need for high quality workmanship when building gardens – the effects of the weather mean that a shoddy finish is quickly apparent as pointing degrades, frosted joints split and badly drained surfaces freeze into ice rinks.  If garden structures are to have any longevity then there is no choice but that the build should be of the highest quality.  No garden designer would quibble with that, or expect anything less from the contractor they appoint to put their ideas into action.

 

Perhaps as a garden designer I am being overly sensitive, but I think I detect, at times an, at best, indifferent attitude to design among some contractors – for some, I feel, the answer to the question could easily be ‘no’.

 

On various threads, in different forums, the unvoiced premise behind some comments might be summarised as ‘designers have never laid so much as a brick in their lives, what do they know about building a garden?  It’s all about pretty plants and farting about with coloured pencils – I can do that for nothing!’  Well, coloured pencils may well be involved, but that doesn’t automatically render (that’s a design pun, by the way) the role of design null and void. 

 

Anybody – client, contractor, designer, passing-kid-on-a-bicycle – can walk into a garden and offer suggestions about the best place for a patio, which tree should come down and whether a pond is going to add anything to the space, but I would argue that for contractors to show their work at its best and for clients to achieve the best result for their space there has to be a degree of design input.  There are obviously well-qualified contractors with a highly developed sense of design who can create beautiful gardens without recourse to a designer, as there are designers with a wide experience of hands-on construction – in each case it’s the knowledge and experience of both aspects that need to be fused to create something of worth.   A jaundiced view of designers is no more constructive than the view of an architect, one of the tutors during my training, which was that contractors are essentially glorified navvies who will wilfully misunderstand a drawing if it’s at all possible. 

 

I’d argue that the relationship has to be symbiotic – I have been working with a trusted contractor over the past year or so, who appreciates the clarity that a designer brings to a project as much as I appreciate nuggets of advice when I suggest something that might be more practically realised by employing a different solution.  In this way there develops a common approach, better designs are evolved and both aspects of the build are enhanced.

If you are one of the lucky ones, a contractor with a highly developed design aesthetic or a designer who loves to mix cement, you will know all this instinctively – if, however, you are unsure of your abilities in either design or construction it makes sense to seek out others who can offer complementary skills.  In a time of economic adversity, just as much as when times are good, it pays to offer the best.

I can’t be at the seminar on 13th April, unfortunately.  It’s at 2pm – if any of you go, let me know the answer!

 

Paul Ridley Design

Email me when people comment –

Comments

  • PRO

    Good thought provoking post Paul.


    I'm not sure if you read - The schism's in design, landscape and horticulture - yesterday? but I added my opinion to an article by John Brookes where he talks of the division between designers and horiculturalists. I think the debate is probably too complex to have a single definitive answer: one of those complexities is the possibility to have such a wide range of skills, ideas, experience(s) vision, expression in both designers and landscape contractors.

    There are probably many designers who have practical skills as well as landscape contractors who have design skills but the range of abilities will vary so much.

    I've worked with many designers and landscapers who I would include instinct as being one of the major assets of their armoury.

    We can read all the books we like - and attend the same amount of seminars - but there are many occasions where it takes instinct to know (or understand) that despite what the book might say, a particular tree or plant may well now thrive or a particular material might not work.

    I too will be interested to hear back from anyone who attends this talk with Mark but I suspect whoever long the discussion goes on for, there won't be enough time;-0)

This reply was deleted.

You need to be a member of Landscape Juice Network to add comments!

Join Landscape Juice Network

Highlighted blog posts

Open forum activity

Andrew Betteridge replied to Andy Sheridan's discussion Tricky customer
"Is that a recent picture or from when the work was first completed?
I assumed there would be signs of movement.
 Andy "
2 minutes ago
Andy Sheridan replied to Andy Sheridan's discussion Tricky customer
""
19 minutes ago
Andy Sheridan replied to Andy Sheridan's discussion Tricky customer
"Hi Andy,
that would seem to be the problem.
I’ve attached a photo of the area in question. We put the gravel drive, block paved threshold and gates in place. The (steeper) tarmac section was already in place. 
The nearest part of the gravel section…"
36 minutes ago
Andrew Betteridge replied to Andy Sheridan's discussion Tricky customer
1 hour ago
Andrew Betteridge replied to Andy Sheridan's discussion Tricky customer
"I’m trying to picture what has happened in my head.
Is there are problem with clay heave? Is the clay pushing the membrane up through the stone?
 Andy "
1 hour ago
Andy Sheridan posted a discussion
Hi all,I’m new on here. Read through some of the threads and have to say I’m very impressed by the advice and knowledge which is being shared.So, perhaps some of you might be able help me put my mind at ease.I have a small company based in Leamingto…
2 hours ago
adrian Stoute is now a member of Hard Landscaping Group
3 hours ago
Ben Carter replied to Neal Rollingson's discussion Tree planting prices?
"Its funny that any rootballed stock that i have planted have done Ok its just the bare root stuff! glad its not just me!
 "
3 hours ago
Scott H replied to David Benson's discussion Bakker,s
3 hours ago
Trevor Stephens posted a discussion
Hi all,One of my clients has a large pond that they now wish to fill in for safety due to new baby and the potential for disaster.They are happy to have it converted into a plant bed, however the initial priority is water out and then filled with th…
4 hours ago
David Benson posted a discussion
i have herd on the grape vine that Bakker of spalding have gon bust for £33M, any body else herd anything my mum is a bit concernd as she has some outstanding plants that are paid for and cannot contact them tried three differant tel no 
5 hours ago
Colin Hunt replied to Ian Bridgford's discussion Repointing a patio
"If the slabs are not soundly bedded, you are opening a can of worms Ian. It could be that the reason for the pointing failing is slight movement, in which case yours could do the same.  
450 X 450 slabs wont take a lot of knocking to dislodge even t…"
8 hours ago
Colin Hunt replied to Neal Rollingson's discussion Tree planting prices?
"I reckon that just about covers it Gary!"
8 hours ago
Colin Hunt replied to Neal Rollingson's discussion Tree planting prices?
"Birch just seem to take exception to being dug up and moved. 
Mind you, we had to move a beautiful 20 years old specimen from an enclosed garden quadrangle which was being redeveloped.  When access was available, we called in Ruskins who soon had it…"
8 hours ago
lee boyce replied to Judi Samuels's discussion Timber groynes installation..
" Would mix concrete up as alot stronger than postcrete which will break up as sleepers are heavy"
13 hours ago
Phil Voice replied to Judi Samuels's discussion Timber groynes installation..
"A little tip.
To kickstart aging of bolts, pop them in a bbq for an hour (especially if they are galvanised). 
 "
15 hours ago
More…

Tricky customer

Hi all, I’m new on here. Read through some of the threads and have to say I’m very impressed by the advice and knowledge which is being shared. So, perhaps some of you might be able help me put my mind at ease. I have a small company based in…

Read more…
5 Replies · Reply by Andrew Betteridge 2 minutes ago

Bakker,s

i have herd on the grape vine that Bakker of spalding have gon bust for £33M, any body else herd anything my mum is a bit concernd as she has some outstanding plants that are paid for and cannot contact them tried three differant tel no 

Read more…
2 Replies · Reply by Scott H 3 hours ago