Christmas trees: are they really sustainable?

Picking up the Christmas tree is a ritual of the season. It may not quite be a case of King Wenceslas trekking into the snowy woods, boots crunching on frozen ground to the distant strains of carols, but there is still a fizz of excitement about the trip to the garden centre, market or farm.

The millions of Christmas trees now sold in the UK spark an annual debate about sustainability. Surely trees should not be cut down, argues the green conscience. Surely trees are a carbon sink, an important part of the landscape and a valuable habitat for wildlife? So, in this season of consumption, what are the best Christmas tree options?

The Telegraph: Christmas trees: are they really sustainable?

Votes: 0
E-mail me when people leave their comments –

Comments

  • I went artificial three years ago, the prices of real trees was going astronomical as the local xmas tree farm said there was a shortage and he had to buy more in from external source. I read that the average size christmas tree takes 10-15 yrs to grow from a 3yr old sapling so I can't imagine its sustainable.

  • Christmas trees are a crop, planted to be cut down and put more in than taken out, so yes IMO they are sustainable.  I supply 4 trees to one of my clients, including a 14' 'biggie' for a vaulted ceiling reception area at an eye-watering £220 and now it is decorated - what a tree!!

This reply was deleted.

You need to be a member of Landscape Juice Network to add comments!

Join Landscape Juice Network

Open forum activity

Honey Badger replied to Tim Bucknall's discussion Stihl blowers failing
"Try a cheap, Chinese charb copy for £20, they do work. Takes a bit of fiddling with though."
4 hours ago
Honey Badger replied to Sam Bainbridge's discussion Niwaki secateurs
"I have two pairs of okatsune secateurs, one for every thing the other for pruning. Japanese steal is the best. 
Would I drop £300 on a pair of secateurs, no.
I'd rather invest in a machine that is far more profitable to use. Like a hedge cutter or a…"
4 hours ago
John F replied to Sam Bainbridge's discussion Niwaki secateurs
"It's like that old analogy do you pay £100 for one pair of shoes or buy ten pairs for £100 .
I tend to compromise and pay £20 for Five pairs .
I am a bit sentimental when it comes to tools and tend to look after them enjoying the fact they have…"
6 hours ago
Adam Woods replied to Sam Bainbridge's discussion Niwaki secateurs
"Very true Sam.... and each to their own
I suppose I am not as disciplined as you..... and tools do occasionally get left where they really shouldnt have been put..... "
9 hours ago
The Wall replied to Tim Bucknall's discussion Stihl blowers failing
"I have one and have to agree with Honey Badger the carb only lasted 3 years, mine was working great had good power then as I was using it just decided to go at half revs quoted £116 for a new one, I have one year left of work undecided what to do…"
22 hours ago
Sam Bainbridge replied to Sam Bainbridge's discussion Niwaki secateurs
"Haven't lost a pair yet and been going for over 15yrs, I always use a holster and if it's not in my hand it's in the holster. As far as spending money goes I think when something is used every day is it wrong to have something that's a pleasure to…"
yesterday
Peter sellers replied to Sam Bainbridge's discussion Niwaki secateurs
"Sorry but am I missing something here? These secateurs and shears are designed to cut plant material. Does spending hundreds mean that somehow you do a better job than us with our £15 Bulldog secateurs from Toolstation that are still sharp after 2…"
yesterday
Adam Woods replied to Sam Bainbridge's discussion Niwaki secateurs
"They would scare me.... not oops where have the red handled Felcos gone, damn, a new pair is going to be the wrontg side of £50.... oh I see them under that shrub :)
But
oops where have the £300 pair of hiryu secateurs gone - do I  service the van…"
Wednesday
Billybop replied to Tim Bucknall's discussion Stihl blowers failing
"Not sad at all Graham if you enjoy doing it, we are all wired up differently and it's very satisfying getting broken machinery running again, my personal issue with repairing machines is I barely get enough time to go out doing jobs with fully…"
Wednesday
Graham Taylor replied to Tim Bucknall's discussion Stihl blowers failing
"I really quite enjoy tinkering around with machinery and sorting them out.... how sad!!       If you have to take things in to a dealer, some machinery just isn't economic to own and that might be the case with a lot of Stihl stuff.  "
Tuesday
Sam Bainbridge posted a discussion
Keep contemplating buying a pair of hiryu secateurs from niwaki wondered if anyone has any and if so what their thoughts are?I've got SR1, tobiso topiary clippers and okatsune shears so I know they are all good but I wondered if the hiryu are worth…
Tuesday
Sam Bainbridge replied to Ricky Watkins's discussion Gardening Business running costs
"Personally I think it's gardeners time to cash in we've been cheap for to long and now that people are lazy we have the pick. I've got 9 big jobs on a waiting list for when I have a gap.not to mention all the small gardens I'm at £35hr now and…"
Dec 20
Will Roberts replied to Tim Bucknall's discussion Stihl blowers failing
"I bought a no name petrol blower on eBay for £30 as temporary fix. I expected it to last 6 months but 2 years later it's still going strong. It's a copy of the Stihl Bg 56. You don't always get what you pay for. "
Dec 20
Billybop replied to Tim Bucknall's discussion Stihl blowers failing
"Hat's off to you for persevering with them Graham. Surely one of the best aspects of British life is blokes patiently and skillfully fixing things in the shed. Sounds a nightmare product to me, whether it was a blower or something else, I wouldn't…"
Dec 20
Fusion Media posted a blog post
Agrovista Amenity has strengthened its team with the appointment of Ben Simpson, who joins as Amenity Specialist supporting the Landscape and IVM division.Ben brings a varied career background and a refreshed enthusiasm for the amenity…
Dec 18
Fusion Media posted a blog post
2025’s prolonged heat put turf surfaces under extraordinary pressure, leaving many venues facing compaction, thinning coverage, and stressed rootzones.As spring approaches, turf professionals are looking to revitalise their surfaces with reliable,…
Dec 17
More…

Niwaki secateurs

Keep contemplating buying a pair of hiryu secateurs from niwaki wondered if anyone has any and if so what their thoughts are?I've got SR1, tobiso topiary clippers and okatsune shears so I know they are all good but I wondered if the hiryu are worth…

Read more…
6 Replies · Reply by Honey Badger 4 hours ago
Views: 104

Making tax digital

Thought there might be some unaware of this. So briefly and I am not an accountant . As from 6th April 26 anyone who has income from self employment, rent from property etc or a combination that equates to a turnover of 50k or more (not profit) will…

Read more…
26 Replies · Reply by Sam Bainbridge Dec 10
Views: 912