Forum

PRO Supplier

After Marshalls' infamous tweet earlier this month, a chat with their Trade Marketing Manager, Liam Poole, at Chelsea last week revealed that he didn't understand why it had created such an outcry (see initial reactions in 50% of sandstone sold in the UK isn't fit for purpose, say Marshalls). "We went out and made sure that all our products met the Standard." Having found that all their paving exceeded the British Standard for external paving, Marshalls then began random testing of paving that's readily available on the market, to find that 50% did not meet this standard. It's worth noting that they did not find anyone trying to pass off sub-standard stone as being of British Standard.

Re-reading their tweet makes the reaction to it clearer:

Phil Voice said, "My issue with Marshalls is not that they are producing stone to a high standard. It was the flippant way that they tweeted initially and then tweeted that if anyone wanted to see their research data then they would have to come to Chelsea and meet them on the Marshalls' stand. 

"I think Marhsalls have probably created an atmosphere where the suppliers of sub-British Standard stone may now be viewed as cowboys."

This feeling certainly seems to have stoked the reaction, as people have, said Liam, been wanting Marshalls to name and shame.  “I think what we need to do is get across that it's not about naming and shaming. What we are trying to say is our product meets the British standard. Most fitters say they meet the British Standard in their work; you should expect the same of the materials."

Marshalls are aiming at a three-pronged approach: to the public, the supplier and installers (many of whom recommend products to their clients). “We're creating a list of three or four questions that installers can ask the merchant and the merchant can ask the supplier. It's all about getting the product you think you are getting."

What Marshall's original tweet doesn't cover, and appears to criticise, is the judicious choice of sub-standard stone. Phil added: “They're looking at this purely from the technical angle. Many landscapers and designers prefer stone that is soft and porous because it gives a garden a much more weathered and lived in feel. I'd even go further and say that many landscapers and designers will go out of their way to use second (or third) grade material - especially reclaimed - so as to achieve an aged look. Chipped and/or slightly blown can add to a garden's charm and appeal.”

The issue, it seems to be agreed, boils down to one main aim. ”Marshalls would have been better concentrating on educating clients on the different applications of stone and advising when it is important to lay a stone that meets with British Standard requirements,” said Phil.

"It's just an education piece,” said Liam. “We're trying to get the message out gently, not beat people over the head with it. We're just trying to say to people to be careful what you are buying. The consumer is so reliant on installer and on merchants. We're trying to say, 'Ask these questions.' Nobody we've come across is trying to mask the issue.”

So, inflammatory tweets (and obvious marketing) aside, it can be said that much of the singing is from the same hymn sheet: more information should be available to the public, so that they understand what they are buying and why. No householder is going to be pleased if an installer lays stone that begins to break up after a single winter, however much that paving is installed in good faith.

Surely ensuring that everyone understands which paving will perform best for what purpose has to be a good thing?

You need to be a member of Landscape Juice Network to add comments!

Join Landscape Juice Network

Email me when people reply –

Landscape industry Jobs

Landscape Operative

Additional landscape operatives required by commercial soft landscape contractor based in Crondall for immediate start. Landscape CSCS/CPCS preferable but not essential as full training given. Competitive salary and advancement opportunities for the… Continue

Junior Gardener

JOB BACKGROUND: Do you have high standards?  Are you able to commit to a role and work hard to maintain those high standards?  Are you keen to start a career in the horticultural industry with a company that will support and train you? Our Junior… Continue

Landscaper

Countryside Services is expanding – we have an increasing amount of bespoke, designed gardens on our books and need new staff. Your commitment to us: to be enthusiastically hard working (in all weathers), keen to learn and prepared to work long… Continue

Gardener

Our client is a successful family business with clients in both the residential and commercial sectors. They are now ready for the business’s next stage of expansion. They really are passionate about gardening and landscaping, providing a vast range… Continue

Latest blog post

Trade green waste centres

Start a landscaping business

LJN Sponsor

Advertising

Technical landscaping books

Blogs

PRO Supplier

ICL paves the way for more games at Pride Park Stadium

Nathan Scarff, Head Groundsman at Derby County FC, has revealed that a range of ICL products have helped him achieve his main target of hosting more games at Pride Park Stadium without compromising on the quality of the pitch.

Nathan…

Read more…
PRO Supplier

After being selected as the official mower at the two most recent FIFA World Cup’s in South Africa and Brazil, Dennis Mowers will be the mower of choice for the 2018 tournament in Russia.

The Dennis G860 cylinder mower will have the task…

Read more…